Why is EMDR so controversial? (2023)

What is controversial about EMDR as a treatment?

The efficacy of EMDR for PTSD is an extremely controversial subject among researchers, as the available evidence can be interpreted in several ways. On one hand, studies have shown that EMDR produces greater reduction in PTSD symptoms compared to control groups receiving no treatment.

(Video) Why EMDR Doesn't Always Work | Kati Morton
(Kati Morton)
Is EMDR bogus?

Pseudoscience. EMDR has been characterized as pseudoscience, because the underlying theory is unfalsifiable. Also, the results of the therapy are non-specific, especially if the eye movement component is irrelevant to the results.

(Video) Is the Eye Movement Element of EMDR Effective?
(Dr. Todd Grande)
When should you not use EMDR?

Because stability must come first, you don't use EMDR to process trauma when a patient is actively abusively using alcohol, drugs, or something to help them feel less. You can't effectively practice EMDR phases 3 – 8 with someone who has yet to experience a safe, trusting relationship.

(Video) Why EMDR doesn’t work for complex PTSD and what actually does
(Sophilia Lark-Woodbury)
Is EMDR considered evidence based?

Eye Movement Desensitization and Reprocessing (EMDR) is an evidence-based treatment for posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD). This means that it has been studied by many researchers and found to be effective in treating PTSD.

(Video) Why do some people report negative experiences with EMDR Psychotherapy?
(The Green Will Conservancy)
Who is not a good candidate for EMDR?

If you're emotions feel overwhelming or if you tend to shut down when you feel an emotion you may not be ready for EMDR treatment. EMDR therapy relies on your body and mind's ability to process through your thoughts and feelings. If you're unable to process in that way, EMDR therapy may not be effective.

(Video) Perspectives on EMDR Therapy and Sexual Health
(Springer Publishing Company)
Can EMDR create false memories?

However, legal cases concerning possible false memories of abuse have revealed that some patients turned out to suffer from false memories of being abused after EMDR therapy (Shaw & Vredeveldt, 2019. (2019).

(Video) Can Moving Your Eyes Re-Code Your Memories?
(SciShow Psych)
Is EMDR just placebo?

EMDR therapy as been found to be relatively equivalent to CBT therapies in seven randomized clinical trials that compared the two approaches. Because the treatment effects are large and clinically meaningful, it can be concluded that EMDR therapy is not a placebo treatment.

(Video) EMDR: Dr. Anadel Barbour Explains The Controversial Therapy & Safe Sex In Sobriety – Ask Dr. Drew
(Dr. Drew)
Can EMDR cause psychosis?

No adverse events were reported, although initial increases in psychotic symptoms were observed in two studies. Average dropout rates across the studies were comparable to other trauma-focused treatments for PTSD.

(Video) Dr. Jennifer Sweeton on PTSD, Trauma & EMDR
(JackHirose&Associates)
Can EMDR cause dissociation?

EMDR is not just another therapy, but a divining rod for dissociation, although this fact was not initially known.

(Video) David Tolin: Pseudoscience in Mental Health Treatments
(PsychiatryLectures)
Can EMDR make you suicidal?

EMDR can quickly treat unprocessed memories and undesirable experiences of life. One of the reasons for this research area experiencing a dearth of studies is because EMDR is not typically recommended for suicidal ideation due to the risk of increasing it.

(Video) What Is EMDR Therapy?
(The ASMR Psychologist)

Why does EMDR not work on some people?

This lack of therapeutic progress happens for two main reasons: Early stress has shaped a nervous system that is unstable and reactive or. The brain and nervous system have gotten very adept at disconnecting from emotions.

(Video) Should EMDR be done at home by yourself?
(The EMDR Coach)
What is the success rate of EMDR?

Several studies have shown that Eye Movement Desensitization and Reprocessing (EMDR) is incredibly effective for those suffering from PTSD, with some showing as much as a 77% success rate.

Why is EMDR so controversial? (2023)
What is the success rate of EMDR?

Several studies have shown that Eye Movement Desensitization and Reprocessing (EMDR) is incredibly effective for those suffering from PTSD, with some showing as much as a 77% success rate.

Is EMDR therapy effective?

EMDR therapy is a relatively new — but very effective — method of helping people with traumatic memories. It's also an option for people of all ages, including children. Though this treatment is best known for its use in treating PTSD, ongoing research shows it can treat many other conditions.

Is EMDR therapy FDA approved?

On Feb. 13, 2014, the FDA published a final rule on Electronic Medical Device Reporting (eMDR) that requires manufacturers and importers to submit MDRs to the FDA in an electronic format that the FDA can process, review, and archive.

Is psychotherapy a pseudoscience?

Certain types of psychotherapy are considered evidence-based for treating some diagnosed mental disorders; other types have been criticized as pseudoscience.
...
Psychotherapy
MeSHD011613
1 more row

You might also like
Popular posts
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Errol Quitzon

Last Updated: 12/13/2022

Views: 6274

Rating: 4.9 / 5 (59 voted)

Reviews: 82% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Errol Quitzon

Birthday: 1993-04-02

Address: 70604 Haley Lane, Port Weldonside, TN 99233-0942

Phone: +9665282866296

Job: Product Retail Agent

Hobby: Computer programming, Horseback riding, Hooping, Dance, Ice skating, Backpacking, Rafting

Introduction: My name is Errol Quitzon, I am a fair, cute, fancy, clean, attractive, sparkling, kind person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.